Immigration Announcement
Federal Court Hears Safe Third Country Charter Challenge
A long running constitutional case has reached a major stage. On November 9, 2026, the Federal Court in Toronto began hearing a Charter challenge to the Canada U.S. Safe Third Country Agreement (STCA). The hearing is scheduled for November 9, 10 and 12, and December 16, 2026. The outcome could shape how Canada handles asylum claims at its southern border.
What Is the STCA?
The STCA is a treaty between Canada and the United States. It generally requires refugee claimants to seek protection in the first safe country they reach. At official land border crossings, this means many claimants who arrive from the U.S. can be turned back and told to make a claim there.
The United States remains the only country designated as a safe third country under Canadian law.
Who Is Challenging It
The applicants include Amnesty International Canada, the Canadian Council for Refugees, the Canadian Council of Churches and former refugee claimants. They argue that returning asylum seekers to the United States under the agreement disproportionately harms racialized women, LGBTQI+ individuals and children.
Their legal claim rests on Section 15 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, the equality rights provision. They are asking the court to strike down the designation of the United States as a safe third country.
Their Main Concerns
The applicants point to risks of detention by U.S. immigration authorities. They also point to the possibility of deportation to countries where claimants may face persecution or other serious harm.
How the Case Got Here
The case has a long history. In 2020, the Federal Court found the agreement violated Section 7 of the Charter, which protects life, liberty and security of the person. In 2021, the Federal Court of Appeal overturned that decision on technical grounds. In 2023, the Supreme Court of Canada sent the Section 15 equality questions back to the Federal Court for consideration. That is the stage now underway.
The Government’s Position
The federal government has continued to say it stands by the designation of the United States as a safe country for refugee claimants. Governments that support the agreement generally argue that it promotes orderly, predictable management of asylum claims between two countries with developed refugee systems. Supporters also note that Canada monitors U.S. practices.
The court will weigh the evidence and the legal arguments from both sides. Nothing has been decided.
Why It Matters
This case speaks to two core Canadian values. One is fair, well managed border and asylum systems. The other is equality and protection for vulnerable people. A court decision either way would carry weight for years.
If the court strikes down the designation, the government could appeal, and the agreement’s status could remain uncertain for some time. If the court upholds it, the applicants may also have avenues to appeal.
What to Watch
Follow the hearing dates. A written decision may not come immediately after hearings end. Judges often take weeks or months to release reasons in complex constitutional cases.
For people considering seeking asylum, current rules remain in force until a court says otherwise. Anyone with a claim should seek advice from a licensed lawyer or a legal clinic and rely on official government sources.
The remaining hearing days are November 10, November 12 and December 16, 2026. We will report on developments as the court proceeds.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is being challenged?
The designation of the United States as a safe third country under the Canada U.S. Safe Third Country Agreement.
On what grounds?
The applicants argue it violates equality rights under Section 15 of the Charter.
Who are the applicants?
Amnesty International Canada, the Canadian Council for Refugees, the Canadian Council of Churches and former refugee claimants.
When are the hearings?
November 9, 10 and 12, and December 16, 2026.
Does the agreement change today?
No. It remains in force unless and until a court rules otherwise.
Want to stay ahead of every change? Follow Canada Immigration News for the latest Canada immigration updates, program changes and court developments. Bookmark our page, subscribe to our updates and check back often. Your Canadian journey deserves reliable information.



